How to format a Substack post, step by step

Format a Substack post with the editor toolbar: headings, bold, links and quotes. Pasted Markdown does not convert, so here is how to fix a draft that does not.

How to format a Substack post, step by step. Cover illustration: a post being composed.

To format a Substack post, use the toolbar in the editor: pick a heading from the Style list, then add bold, italic, links, quotes and lists. If your draft is in Markdown, don't expect the editor to convert it when you paste it; our free Substack post formatter does that conversion first.

This guide covers the editor's formatting options, why pasted Markdown stays as symbols, how to move a draft over from Google Docs or an AI chat, and what to check before you publish. Sources are listed at the end, and we say where a claim comes from community reports rather than Substack itself.

What formatting does the Substack editor have?

As of November 2026, Substack's own guide to the editor lists a core set: a Style list for headings, bold, italic, strikethrough, code, links, block quotes, and bulleted and numbered lists. Substack has also added a highlighter.

That is enough for most newsletters. It is a deliberately simple editor, so there are no custom fonts or font sizes to fiddle with. If a style isn't on the toolbar, treat it as unavailable and write around it.

How to format a Substack post in the editor

You can do all of the following without leaving the post you are writing.

  1. Add headings. Select the line, open the Style list on the toolbar and choose a heading. Use one level for each major section.
  2. Style words. Select them and use Bold, Italic or Strikethrough on the toolbar. Keep bold for the few lines you most want a skimmer to see.
  3. Add links. Select the text and use the link button. Link words that say where they go, not "click here".
  4. Add a quote or list. Use the block quote button for a pulled quote, and the bulleted or numbered list buttons for steps and options.
  5. Preview, then publish. Look at the draft as a reader would before you send it.

Can you paste Markdown into Substack?

Mostly no. Community write-ups from writers who tried it report that pasted Markdown comes through as plain text, with the pound signs and asterisks still in place. We found no official Substack statement either way, so treat this as what writers report, not a promise.

The workaround those writers describe is the same each time: turn the Markdown into formatted text first, then paste that. They do it with a converter or a preview that renders the Markdown, and then copy the rendered result, not the source.

Test with a short sample in a draft before you move a whole post. It takes a minute, and it tells you how your version of the editor behaves today.

Markdown to Substack: what each symbol becomes

Every common Markdown element has a toolbar equivalent. This is the map to use when you convert by hand, or when you check a converter's output.

MarkdownSubstack elementWhere
## HeadingHeadingStyle list
**bold**BoldToolbar
*italic*ItalicToolbar
~~gone~~StrikethroughToolbar
[words](url)LinkLink button
> quoteBlock quoteToolbar
- itemBulleted listToolbar
1. stepNumbered listToolbar
Markdown on the left, the Substack editor feature it becomes on the right. All eight are on the standard toolbar.

Use the Substack formatter to convert a draft

If you write in Markdown, or an AI assistant gave you a draft in it, you can skip the manual map. The free Substack post formatter turns Markdown into formatted text and shows a preview. It runs in your browser, so your draft is not sent to a server.

  1. Paste your Markdown into the formatter.
  2. Read the preview. Headings, lists, quotes and links should look the way you want.
  3. Copy the formatted result.
  4. Paste it into a new Substack draft, then check the headings and links once before you publish.

Check the first paste each time. Editors change, and a thirty-second look is cheaper than a broken newsletter in a thousand inboxes.

Google Docs to Substack

We could not find official Substack guidance on pasting from Google Docs or Word, so we won't promise what survives. The general pattern across editors is that simple formatting such as bold and links carries over more reliably than headings, which can arrive as bold text instead of real headings.

A safe routine is to paste a short section first and see what happened. If headings or links break, paste as plain text and reapply them with the toolbar. That is our suggestion, not a Substack-documented step.

  • Headings: check each one is a real heading, not bold body text.
  • Links: click one to make sure it opens the right page.
  • Lists: make sure each item is its own bullet.

Substack Notes formatting and bold text

Notes have their own composer. Substack's own account says it supports bold, italics, strikethrough, bulleted and numbered lists, quotes and code. One writer's tip says Markdown-style shortcuts work while typing in Notes on desktop, which we have not confirmed.

The key difference from LinkedIn is that you do not need look-alike characters for bold on Substack, because the editor has real bold. See why in how to bold text on LinkedIn, where the workaround is a necessity.

Share your Substack post everywhere with TrackMedia

A formatted post is only half the job. Readers find a newsletter through the posts you share on other networks, and writing each version by hand is slow. TrackMedia takes one draft, adapts it for each network, schedules it and shows which post earned the clicks.

If you are new to sharing one piece in many places, read how to cross-post on social media, how to post to all social media at once and how to manage multiple social media accounts. The formatter is free whether or not you ever sign up.

Questions people also ask

How do I bold text in Substack?

Select the words in the editor and click Bold on the toolbar. Substack's editor has real bold, so no special characters are needed.

How do I add headings in Substack?

Select the line, open the Style list on the toolbar and choose a heading.

Does Substack support Markdown?

Writers report that pasted Markdown stays as plain symbols. Convert it to formatted text first, for example with the free Substack formatter, and check the result in a draft.

Can I paste from Google Docs into Substack?

Yes, you can paste, but check headings and links afterwards because we found no official guidance on what carries over.

Why does my Substack post show asterisks?

You pasted Markdown, and the editor kept the symbols as text. Convert the draft to formatted text, or style the words with the toolbar.

How we checked this

We searched on November 20, 2026 and read what each source says. We did not test every paste on a live Substack account. We could not find the Help Center's wording on pasting, so those points come from writers and are labeled that way.

Post once and publish to all social media channels for only $8.25 per month

Start on the free plan with 10 accounts and 15 posts a month. Move to Creator for $99 a year when you need 30 accounts.

No card required Every network in every plan Plans from $99 a year